The New York Yankees have found themselves in a precarious situation as they approach the postseason. Injuries, a persistent theme in their 2024 campaign, have now taken a toll on first baseman Anthony Rizzo, casting doubt on the team’s playoff aspirations. A recent injury acquired from being struck by a pitch during a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates has elevated concerns within the organization. Rizzo’s health now becomes a focal point as the Yankees fight not just for a playoff berth, but for a chance to contend for a championship.
During a game marred by a 9-4 defeat against the Pittsburgh Pirates, Rizzo’s injury occurred in the seventh inning when he got hit by an 88 mph slider thrown by left-handed pitcher Ryan Borucki. The moment was agonizing—Rizzo instinctively clutched his hand, signaling distress and leading to immediate medical attention. Although he managed to remain in the game briefly to fulfill running duties, his absence from the field in the subsequent inning raises red flags regarding the severity of the injury.
Manager Aaron Boone’s remarks post-game did little to assuage concerns. He noted that Rizzo’s condition remains uncertain, emphasizing that while his injury does not automatically exclude him from playoff participation, the situation will likely hinge on Rizzo’s pain tolerance. The Yankees’ season finale looms on the horizon, leaving fans and management to wonder if Rizzo will be able to contribute when it matters most.
Rizzo’s Struggles and Performance Metrics
Rizzo’s performance in 2024 can best be described as lackluster, even before his latest injury. Across 92 games, he recorded career lows in batting average (.228), on-base percentage (.301), and slugging percentage (.335). The eight home runs he managed this season are far below expectations for a player with his pedigree. His struggles have prompted questions regarding the efficacy of retaining him for the following season, especially given his $17 million team option and a $6 million buyout.
Further complicating matters was Rizzo’s previous extended absence due to a fractured forearm sustained in June. This prolonged injury contributed to his dismal offensive output, as he struggled to find his form upon returning from the injured list in September. His lack of home runs and overall production could signal an alarming trend; one that raises questions about his durability and performance level as he ages in his 14th MLB season.
In the wake of Rizzo’s injury, Boone has identified Ben Rice and Oswaldo Cabrera as viable alternatives at first base should Rizzo be unable to return. Rice, initially called up to cover for Rizzo’s earlier injury, demonstrated promise with a strong start—recording three home runs in a single game against the Red Sox. However, his performance regressed significantly over the ensuing weeks, culminating in a demotion to Triple-A after struggling to maintain consistent offensive production.
Cabrera presents another option, having filled in at first base on several occasions this season. His statistics show that he has managed a batting average of .247 alongside a .661 OPS—numbers that are acceptable yet far from spectacular. The Yankees need more than mediocrity to make a successful postseason run, which places immense pressure on whoever occupies first base in Rizzo’s absence.
The impending postseason represents a critical juncture for the Yankees. Rizzo’s capacity to recover in time for the playoff games could significantly shape the team’s fortunes. If he is able to play, his experience and defensive capabilities are invaluable; however, if he cannot recover, the Yankees must rely on relatively inexperienced players to fill the gap.
As the organization grapples with these emerging challenges, it must remain agile, adjusting strategies to compensate for player absences. The coming week will unveil whether the Yankees can adapt effectively and whether they can overcome their offensive woes in the face of mounting adversity. The stakes are higher now than ever, and every decision made in the limited time left could define their fate in the postseason.